The Society of Food Hygiene Technology print pageclose window

Hygiene Review 1998

THE CHALLENGES TO FOOD RETAILING

Una Crilly, Food Safety Manager - Dunnes Stores

Dunnes Stores are committed to selling safe, quality foods to our customers. All food must be handled safely from the production site through distribution and into our stores. Food Safety must be planned and requires appropriately deployed resources with the implementation of effective hazard analysis, control and monitoring systems and a comprehensive training programme for food handlers. The adoption of a flexible system based on Hazard Analysis and Risk Assessment has resulted in improved standards in our stores.

At Dunnes Stores our Food Technologists inspect our suppliers premises to ensure compliance with our Quality standard and to ensure the products are being handled in a safe manner.

At present we are implementing our Food Safety system in to all stores. This system is based on HACCP. The hazard analysis will identify the specific controls required at each step in the operation. The key to food safety is to ensure the competency of staff at each stage of the chain and documented systems, which can be audited by our Managers to demonstrate that all control measures are implemented.

Several Environmental Health graduates are employed as Food Safety Managers for stores. They assist with the implementation of the Food Safety system, audit stores to the required standard and carry out regular Food Hygiene training in our stores.

It is the objective of Dunnes Stores to supply safe, quality food to our customers in a clean and pleasant shopping environment. To achieve this objective, Dunnes Stores apply rigorous standards of hygiene, to ensure:-

  • Our stores are of the highest standard of visual cleanliness and provide a pleasant shopping environment for our customers;
  • There is a pleasant working environment for Dunnes Stores personnel;
  • We sell good quality , safe food;
  • We minimise wastage due to poor handling;
  • We prevent contamination of food and cross contamination. ( Raw and cooked separation)
  • We create good working conditions with a "Clean as you go" policy in operation throughout the store;
  • We develop a good hygiene awareness and understand the principles of Food Safety;

The success of Good Hygiene Management depends on teamwork in our stores and ensuring that everybody takes responsibility for the hygiene and good practices in their place of work. To ensure high standards of Food safety in our stores we have implemented a Food Safety Control system based on Hazard Analysis Critical Control Point (HACCP) system.

There were a number of challenges addressed when implementing such a Food Safety System. The retail business has changed over the past number of years with increased opening hours and seven-day trading. The consistency of standards in the stores is essential and thus there must be a structured approach to both the cleaning operations and the food safety controls.

1. Documentation of all hygiene standards:

The first stage was to ensure that there was a good basic standard of hygiene in all the stores. There must be clear guidelines given to all employees and enforced as Company policy. It is important, that the management should observe these regulations also, for example Personal Hygiene regulations. Should they fail to do so the staff will be demotivated.

The codes of practice were compiled in great detail based on joint visits with Environmental Heath Officers, customer complaints, the Retail guidelines from NSAI and advice given by Independent Food Safety Consultants. The codes were documented in the Dunnes Stores "Food Safety Manual and were detailed per department in the store. These were the Good Hygiene Practices required in every department in the store and were written in simple terms with visual aids to ensure easy reading.

2. Documentation of the Food Safety System

Effective implementation of HACCP requires a preliminary risk assessment and to define the food safety objectives. These objectives allow to prioritize risks, to apportionate resources, to identify and validate CCPs and their critical limits and to establish the systems.

Each system was compiled in such a way that it was user-friendly and easily understood particularly by junior members of staff or Management. The documented systems Save all the necessary information to understand how each critical food safety point was controlled. i.e. The temperature control system states:- The date, time, name of checker, name of product in the area , temperature of the chill, recheck when poor temperatures and details of any action taken. The monitoring procedure was documented at the bottom of the sheet to ensure the checker was aware of the procedure at all times. Each checker completed the specific training in how to complete the checks correctly as part of the HACCP training programme.

The in-store systems that were compiled were as follows: -

  • Temperature monitoring - Chilled & frozen units
  • Hot food production and display controls
  • Stock rotation
  • Cleaning Schedules
  • Mince control system

The systems were compiled by liaising closely with the Environmental Health Officers to ensure compliance with the current and pending Food Hygiene legislation.

3. Link with Purchasing / Technical departments

The Food Safety Controls prior to arriving at the stores are controlled by the purchasing and the Technical departments. Supplier audits are completed by the Technical team to ensure compliance with the Dunnes Stores Quality standard.

The deliveries of food to the stores are spot-checked to a specific quality and hygiene standard. The details referring to non-conforming deliveries are communicated to Head Office to enable the Technical / Purchasing team to follow up the problems with the supplier. This communication link and follow up action is vital to ensure there are consistent standards of product being delivered to our stores to the required specification.

The in-store traceability system was set up in the fresh food departments to ensure all opened foods were traceable to the supplier at every stage of the process. Documented systems were established to identify the internal shelf life of all fresh produce and was traceable to the time of production in the factory.

4.Good Hygiene Practices

Before a HACCP/Food Safety system could be introduced there must be a sound hygiene base. Good practices must be implemented with a clean as you go policy in every department. The highest standards of hygiene were enforced by Management at every level. Clear, colourful hygiene signage was developed with relevant graphics to highlight the instructions. These were placed in appropriate locations to remind staff of the good hygiene practices, which should be in operation in Dunnes Stores.

5. Personalized systems per store

The Food Safety and Cleaning Schedules were personalized per store. Plans were drawn of each department to be used for temperature monitoring and cleaning schedules. The departmental cleaning programmes were planned and agreed in advance thus the frequency of cleaning was standardized per department in every store in the group.

Cleaning schedules in the delicatessen areas were compiled by listing every piece of equipment in the area. The completed cleaning schedules were spot-checked by Management by doing a cross-comparison between the record and the relevant equipment, which was cleaned. This was to ensure the completed schedules reflected the actual cleaning standards.

6. Commercial involvement

Hygiene is an important part of the role of the Store Manager through the active support from Commercial Managers at a Senior level. The roles and responsibilities at each level within the Commercial Management structure were defined concisely to ensure the management of hygiene was an integral part of the day to day management routine.

HACCP checklists were compiled for department Managers, Store Managers and Area Managers to ensure that there was a consistency of standards of hygiene in the stores.

7. Systems implementation

Food Safety Managers were recruited to provide specialized training in the stores. These were mainly Environmental Health Graduates who would have a sound knowledge of the legislative requirements. The role of the Food Safety Manager was to ensure all systems were implemented properly, provide the necessary training to Managers and Staff and to audit the stores thereafter. Generally the Food Safety Managers would raise the awareness of Food Safety and Hygiene in the stores.

8. Training

The specific information from the Food Safety Manual became part of the overall training for each employee. The relevant hygiene / food safety details were issued as a Quality Standard. This training would provide the detailed codes of practice relevant to each department. An in-house certified induction hygiene course is provided to food handlers.

All Management required initial basic hygiene training, an introduction to HACCP workshop and more detailed Food Safety training. The training was provided both in-house and by external training providers, Formal HACCP training workshops for Management were a forum to discuss the purpose of the Food Safety system and Managers could actually devise HACCP systems for various products. The course also highlighted each person's role and responsibilities to ensure that the HACCP system worked effectively.

9. Measuring hygiene standards -Verification process

Measurement of hygiene standards was essential to ensure consistency in stores throughout the country. The Managers were always advised on the improvement or drop in standards in the store but a precise score indicated the actual standard compared to other stores. Thus a structured method of measuring the food safety system and hygiene standards was set up. This proved an extremely successful approach by placing a competitive aspect to the hygiene standards in the different stores.

The Food Safety system and hygiene standards were measured at different levels i.e. In-store audits, Area Manager audits, Head Office audits and audits by Independent Food Safety Consultants. All audits reports were working documents indicating the problems found during the inspection but also the Store Manager documented all relevant action taken in the store to prevent a repetition of the problem.

This verification process is performed after the Food Safety system is implemented to check whether the system is working. This is carried out both internally and externally and the system is updated where necessary. The audit process is a systematic and independent examination to determine whether our food safety system is correctly established, effectively implemented and suitable to achieve our objectives.

The Dunnes Stores National Hygiene Championship

The introduction of a National Hygiene Competition throughout Ireland has been a very successful method of motivating both staff and Management to raise standards of hygiene in all stores. Independent Food Safety Consultants complete rigorous detailed checks on the whole HACCP system twice yearly. This is an extremely effective method of ensuring the highest standards in the stores and that all systems are working,

10. Review of the Food Safety System

Each year all systems are reviewed to ensure the control system is working as effectively as possible. All common problems highlighted through the audits were addressed and capital invested where necessary. The review of the system highlighted policies, roles, systems or training information that need to be amended. The Food Safety manual and training information is updated each year. Joint visits with Environmental Health Officers will incorporate changing public health concerns into the system and all points are added to the revised version of the Food Safety Manual. A rigorous risk assessment should provide the basis for monitoring problems and changes in food safety risks and to identify priorities for action.

The Dunnes Stores Food Safety system is an action -orientated system, which controls hazards associated with the food products, the in-store processes, personnel, equipment and environmental factors. This is a proactive approach to Food Safety by focusing control at points in the operation, which are critical to Food Safety. Dunnes Stores are very committed to Food Safety and Hygiene in our stores. The involvement of Managers at every level is vital to ensure this Food Safety system works effectively and that it will be maintained particularly during peak trading periods.

The Society of Food Hygiene and Technology, The Granary, Middleton House Farm, Tamworth Road, Middleton, Staffs, B78 2BD, UK
Tel +44 (0)1827 872500   Fax +44 (0)1827 875800   Email
admin@sofht.co.uk